Courts are clearly struggling with the law governing the tensions between faculty and student free speech rights in the classroom, and the results are murky at best. There is no current clear precedent as to the standards to be applied to students, or the level of actual deference that will be given to educational decisions. While courts continue to pay lip service to the “deference” owed academic decisions within colleges and universities, the application of the law to the facts suggests otherwise, and the difficulty of applying traditional First Amendment legal standards to the unusual situation presented by higher education will continue. Courts will continue to struggle with the question of how to balance the academic freedom rights of students against the academic freedom rights of institutions and faculty members, and will hopefully continue to recognize that the curricular speech of faculty in the classroom, assuming its germaneness to the subject matter, must be deferred to as professional judgments unless substantial evidence suggests otherwise.
Thus it is that having argued that Star Wars is a Western, thebody of the paper is going to have to first establish theelements that comprise the Westernit will have to establishthe criteria by which the thesis can be proven. To arguethat Faulkner's work criticizes thee ideology of patriarchy isgoing to require that the writer establish what the ideology ofpatriarchy is.
Example of a non-debatable thesis statement:
If you keep it clear to yourself that the purpose of theintroduction to your essay is to only INTRODUCE your theoreticalframework, and your thesis statement, then the function of thebody of your essay will also become evident to the reader. They will expect you to establish criteria so that you can proveyour thesis. As a result, another important norm of theacademic essay is:
Njit Thesis - Establishing A Thesis Statement
In general, students who are at the end of their junior year, have an overall 3.2 GPA, and meet their departmental requirements can write a senior thesis. For information about your eligibility, contact:
Establishing a Purpose and a Thesis | Boundless …
Following this norm allows you to cut to the chase. Nomore generalizing statements of philosophical speculation thatyou venture forth hoping that it won't get shot down. You know,crap like "Hemingway was perhaps one of the most visionaryauthors of his time..." or "The Western is perhaps themost uniquely American of all the genres..." Rather,if the purpose of the essay is to demonstrate that you haveappropriated a theory and applied it independently to produceresults, then the function of the introduction becomes morefocused: to introduce the theoryor theoreticalframeworkthat you have decided to use. Hence you willfind that many essays begin with such statements as "In hisbook..." Or, "In her essay..."
Establishing a Purpose and a Thesis
Although the scope of your paper might seem overwhelming at the start, generally the narrower the thesis the more effective your argument will be. Your thesis or claim must be supported by evidence. The broader your claim is, the more evidence you will need to convince readers that your position is right.
How to write a thesis proposal on your own
Satisfy your intellectual curiosity
This is the most compelling reason to write a thesis. Whether it’s the short stories of Flannery O’Connor or the challenges of urban poverty, you’ve studied topics in college that really piqued your interest. Now’s your chance to follow your passions, explore further, and contribute some original ideas and research in your field.